# Shield Law on The No Agenda Show Shield Law comes up in 19 chapters across 16 episodes of The No Agenda Show, from February 2011 to February 2025. - **Chapters:** 19 - **Episodes:** 16 - **Discussed:** February 2011 – February 2025 - **Related topics:** [Journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md), [Chuck Schumer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/chuck-schumer.md), [Bloggers](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/bloggers.md), [First Amendment](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/first-amendment.md), [Barack Obama](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/barack-obama.md), [Constitution](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/constitution.md), [Freedom Of The Press](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/freedom-of-the-press.md), [Glenn Greenwald](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/glenn-greenwald.md), [Mark Shields](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/mark-shields.md), [National Security](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/national-security.md) ## Chapters 1–19 of 19 ### Legal Action Against Medical Journals for Racketeering - **Episode:** [1738: Swasticars](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/1738-swasticars.md) - **Published:** 2025-02-13 - **Time:** 6:36–8:25 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/1738-swasticars/chapter/legal-action-against-medical-journals-for-racketeering.md Robert F. Kennedy Jr. intends to involve the Justice Department in investigating major medical journals like The Lancet and JAMA for alleged collaboration with the pharmaceutical industry. He characterizes their actions as a "racketeering syndicate" that misleads the public on product safety. Additionally, he signaled a desire to address the vaccine shield law that provides liability protection to manufacturers. Keywords: [lancet](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/lancet.md), [jama](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/jama.md), [department of justice](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/department-of-justice.md), [racketeering](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/racketeering.md), vaccine shield law ### Anne Neuberger, White House Cyber Call to Action, and CISA - **Episode:** [1436: Frog of War](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/1436-frog-of-war.md) - **Published:** 2022-03-24 - **Time:** 1:30:12–1:35:36 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/1436-frog-of-war/chapter/anne-neuberger-white-house-cyber-call-to-action-and-cisa.md White House cyber advisor Anne Neuberger delivered a "call to action" urging private sector partners to harden their digital defenses against potential Russian retaliation. While admitting there is "no certainty" of an attack, she highlighted the administration's "Shields Up" program and the need for new congressional authorities to monitor corporate networks. The hosts interpret this as a push for greater government integration into private sector technology. Keywords: anne neuberger, [white house](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/white-house.md), [cyber security](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/cyber-security.md), [cisa](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/cisa.md), shields up, infrastructure law ### Media Shield Law, Jimmy Fallon Board - **Episode:** [587: People the Board](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/587-people-the-board.md) - **Published:** 2014-02-01 - **Time:** 2:49:56–2:54:28 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/587-people-the-board/chapter/media-shield-law-jimmy-fallon-board.md Attorney General Eric Holder discusses the "Free Flow of Information Act," a media shield law that would require journalists to be licensed by the government. Holder mentions a "people board" being assembled to oversee the process, which the hosts mock as a violation of the First Amendment. The show concludes with a reminder of the "value for value" model and a sign-off for the next episode. Keywords: [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [eric holder](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/eric-holder.md), [chuck schumer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/chuck-schumer.md), [jimmy fallon](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/jimmy-fallon.md), [freedom of the press](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/freedom-of-the-press.md) ### Media Shield Law, Glenn Greenwald and Bill Maher - **Episode:** [584: Hybrid Pigs](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/584-hybrid-pigs.md) - **Published:** 2014-01-20 - **Time:** 43:05–49:36 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/584-hybrid-pigs/chapter/media-shield-law-glenn-greenwald-and-bill-maher.md The discussion examines Glenn Greenwald's appearance on Bill Maher's show and the push for a Media Shield Law. The hosts argue that the government is attempting to define who is a "licensed" journalist to exclude independent internet media and whistleblowers like Edward Snowden. Keywords: [glenn greenwald](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/glenn-greenwald.md), [bill maher](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/bill-maher.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md), [edward snowden](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/edward-snowden.md) ### Introduction, Ham Radio and Media Shield Law Predictions - **Episode:** [548: Mournful Mortician](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/548-mournful-mortician.md) - **Published:** 2013-09-15 - **Time:** 1:35 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/548-mournful-mortician/chapter/introduction-ham-radio-and-media-shield-law-predictions.md Adam Curry and John C. Dvorak open episode 548 from Austin, Texas and Northern Silicon Valley. They discuss their signal strength using ham radio terminology before transitioning into a discussion about the Senate's agreement on a media shield law. Dvorak notes he predicted the move toward journalist licensing in his earlier writings about the impact of blogging on traditional media. Keywords: [adam curry](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/adam-curry.md), [john c. dvorak](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/john-c-dvorak.md), [gitmo nation](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/gitmo-nation.md), [austin](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/austin.md), [silicon valley](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/silicon-valley.md), [blogging](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/blogging.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md) ### Senate Media Shield Law, Journalist Licensing and Elitism - **Episode:** [548: Mournful Mortician](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/548-mournful-mortician.md) - **Published:** 2013-09-15 - **Time:** 1:35–6:50 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/548-mournful-mortician/chapter/senate-media-shield-law-journalist-licensing-and-elitism.md The Senate Judiciary Committee approved a media shield law defining "covered journalists" based on specific employment durations and affiliations. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, featuring mainstream figures like Wolf Blitzer and Andrea Mitchell, supports the bill despite its limitations. Critics argue the law creates an elitist tier of licensed journalists and violates the First Amendment by allowing Congress to define who qualifies for protection. Keywords: [chuck schumer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/chuck-schumer.md), [senate judiciary committee](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/senate-judiciary-committee.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [wolf blitzer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/wolf-blitzer.md), [andrea mitchell](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/andrea-mitchell.md), constitutional amendments, licensedjournalist.com ### David Brooks, Mark Shields, International Law Debate - **Episode:** [544: Arab Winter](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/544-arab-winter.md) - **Published:** 2013-09-01 - **Time:** 1:08:21–1:16:15 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/544-arab-winter/chapter/david-brooks-mark-shields-international-law-debate.md On PBS NewsHour, commentators David Brooks and Mark Shields debated the merits of striking Syria. Brooks, appearing nervous, argued that the U.S. must act to maintain the "non-proliferation regime," while Shields pointed out the lack of a coalition and the "poisoning of the well" from the Iraq War. The hosts criticize Brooks for ignoring that a strike without UN approval would violate international law. Keywords: [david brooks](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/david-brooks.md), [mark shields](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/mark-shields.md), [pbs news hour](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/pbs-news-hour.md), [international law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/international-law.md), mustard gas ### Media Shield Law, Investigative Journalism, and Classified Information - **Episode:** [541: Huge Samoan](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/541-huge-samoan.md) - **Published:** 2013-08-22 - **Time:** 13:05–16:20 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/541-huge-samoan/chapter/media-shield-law-investigative-journalism-and-classified-information.md Glenn Greenwald argues that the possession of classified information is a fundamental component of investigative journalism, citing historical examples like the Pentagon Papers and reports on CIA black sites. The discussion explores the implications of the proposed Media Shield Law, which would legally define who qualifies as a journalist and who receives protection. Greenwald asserts that criminalizing the handling of leaked documents effectively demands that citizens remain ignorant of government actions. Keywords: [glenn greenwald](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/glenn-greenwald.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [investigative journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/investigative-journalism.md), [classified information](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/classified-information.md), [the guardian](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/the-guardian.md), [pentagon papers](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/pentagon-papers.md) ### Media Shield Law, Dianne Feinstein Journalist Definition - **Episode:** [539: Assume the Position](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/539-assume-the-position.md) - **Published:** 2013-08-15 - **Time:** 1:42:38–1:49:41 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/539-assume-the-position/chapter/media-shield-law-dianne-feinstein-journalist-definition.md Senate Bill 987, the Media Shield Law, is criticized as an unconstitutional attempt by Congress to define who qualifies as a journalist. Senator Dianne Feinstein added an amendment requiring journalists to be salaried employees or independent contractors of established news entities to receive protection. This definition excludes bloggers and independent media creators, effectively creating a "podcast license" requirement for legal protection. Keywords: [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [dianne feinstein](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/dianne-feinstein.md), [chuck schumer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/chuck-schumer.md), [first amendment](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/first-amendment.md), [journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md), [bloggers](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/bloggers.md) ### First Amendment, Proposed Media Shield Law - **Episode:** [530: Boston Brakes](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/530-boston-brakes.md) - **Published:** 2013-07-14 - **Time:** 20:42–24:39 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/530-boston-brakes/chapter/first-amendment-proposed-media-shield-law.md The hosts review the Department of Justice's new policies regarding subpoenas and search warrants targeting the press. They argue that the administration is pushing for a "Media Shield Law" that would actually codify government interference and define who qualifies as a legitimate journalist, potentially undermining the First Amendment. Keywords: [first amendment](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/first-amendment.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [freedom of the press](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/freedom-of-the-press.md), [subpoenas](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/subpoenas.md), [search warrants](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/search-warrants.md), [constitution](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/constitution.md) ### Trevor Timm, Freedom of the Press Foundation - **Episode:** [530: Boston Brakes](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/530-boston-brakes.md) - **Published:** 2013-07-14 - **Time:** 28:36–31:26 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/530-boston-brakes/chapter/trevor-timm-freedom-of-the-press-foundation.md The hosts call out Trevor Timm of the Freedom of the Press Foundation for advocating for a media shield law. They argue that Timm, despite his background with the EFF and ACLU, is supporting legislation that would allow the government to decide who is a journalist, which they view as a betrayal of constitutional principles. Keywords: trevor timm, [freedom of the press foundation](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/freedom-of-the-press-foundation.md), james goodale, [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [aclu](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/aclu.md), [eff](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/eff.md) ### James Comey FBI Confirmation and HSBC Ties - **Episode:** [529: No Coup](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/529-no-coup.md) - **Published:** 2013-07-11 - **Time:** 1:01:51–1:09:47 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/529-no-coup/chapter/james-comey-fbi-confirmation-and-hsbc-ties.md The confirmation hearing of James Comey for FBI Director is critiqued, specifically his previous role on the board of HSBC during its money laundering settlement. Comey's stance on "shield laws" for journalists is discussed, with the hosts arguing that any legislative "carve-out" for national security renders the First Amendment protections moot. Keywords: [james comey](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/james-comey.md), [fbi](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/fbi.md), [hsbc](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/hsbc.md), [money laundering](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/money-laundering.md), [waterboarding](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/waterboarding.md), [shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/shield-law.md) ### Senator Dick Durbin, First Amendment and Journalist Definitions - **Episode:** [517: Chubby Hitler](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/517-chubby-hitler.md) - **Published:** 2013-05-30 - **Time:** 6:16–10:32 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/517-chubby-hitler/chapter/senator-dick-durbin-first-amendment-and-journalist-definitions.md Senator Dick Durbin questioned the definition of a journalist in the 21st century during a televised discussion regarding media shield laws. Durbin suggested that while traditional outlets like Fox News and the AP are clearly protected, bloggers and Twitter users may not be entitled to the same constitutional protections under the First Amendment. This perspective draws criticism for ignoring the historical context of 18th-century pamphlets and independent publishing. Keywords: [dick durbin](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/dick-durbin.md), [first amendment](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/first-amendment.md), [constitution](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/constitution.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [bloggers](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/bloggers.md), [journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md) ### Media Shield Law, National Security Provisions and MSNBC Analysis - **Episode:** [517: Chubby Hitler](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/517-chubby-hitler.md) - **Published:** 2013-05-30 - **Time:** 10:32–14:47 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/517-chubby-hitler/chapter/media-shield-law-national-security-provisions-and-msnbc-analysis.md The Obama administration's push for a media shield law follows investigations into the Associated Press and Fox News reporters. Critics argue that such a law is redundant because the First Amendment already serves as a shield, and new legislation would likely include national security exceptions that render it ineffective for whistleblowers. Analysis of MSNBC coverage featuring Martin Bashir and Crystal Ball suggests a partisan defense of the administration's transparency record. Keywords: [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [barack obama](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/barack-obama.md), [msnbc](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/msnbc.md), [martin bashir](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/martin-bashir.md), crystal ball, [national security](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/national-security.md) ### Obama Press Conference and Police State Announcement - **Episode:** [515: Wantonly Podcasting](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/515-wantonly-podcasting.md) - **Published:** 2013-05-23 - **Time:** 2:32:36–2:35:59 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/515-wantonly-podcasting/chapter/obama-press-conference-and-police-state-announcement.md President Obama's recent press conference is characterized as the finalization of a police state, covering topics such as drone strikes and media shield laws. The hosts prepare for a deep deconstruction of the administration's announcements in the upcoming Sunday broadcast. Keywords: [barack obama](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/barack-obama.md), [police state](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/police-state.md), [media shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/media-shield-law.md), [drones](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/drones.md), holiday weekend ### Shield Law Irony and Jay Carney Transparency Claims - **Episode:** [514: Patriotic Printer](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/514-patriotic-printer.md) - **Published:** 2013-05-19 - **Time:** 22:23–27:15 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/514-patriotic-printer/chapter/shield-law-irony-and-jay-carney-transparency-claims.md The irony of the Obama administration proposing a new journalist Shield Law while simultaneously surveilling the Associated Press is examined. Critics argue the law contains a "national security exception" that renders it useless for protecting whistleblowers. White House Press Secretary Jay Carney is shown defending the administration's transparency record during an interview with Piers Morgan, which the hosts dismiss as deceptive. Keywords: [chuck schumer](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/chuck-schumer.md), [shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/shield-law.md), [jay carney](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/jay-carney.md), [benghazi](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/benghazi.md), [piers morgan](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/piers-morgan.md), [national security](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/national-security.md) ### Kosovo Press Freedom, Source Protection and EU Penal Code - **Episode:** [420: The Data Hole](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/420-the-data-hole.md) - **Published:** 2012-06-24 - **Time:** 22:37–23:22 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/420-the-data-hole/chapter/kosovo-press-freedom-source-protection-and-eu-penal-code.md Kosovo's Justice Minister resigned following the passage of a new penal code that reportedly undermines press freedom. The articles in question require journalists to reveal their sources if a court warrant is issued, a move aligned with broader European Union trends. The discussion suggests this marks the decline of independent journalism within the Eurozone. Keywords: [kosovo](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/kosovo.md), [press freedom](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/press-freedom.md), [european union](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/european-union.md), [shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/shield-law.md), [journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md) ### New Jersey Blogger Ruling, Federal Shield Law - **Episode:** [312: Illegal in Tennessee](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/312-illegal-in-tennessee.md) - **Published:** 2011-06-12 - **Time:** 2:05:33–2:13:29 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/312-illegal-in-tennessee/chapter/new-jersey-blogger-ruling-federal-shield-law.md The New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that a blogger is not a protected journalist under state law, specifically regarding the protection of anonymous sources. The hosts discuss the implications of a "two-tier" system for journalists and the push for a federal shield law, featuring commentary from Judy Miller. Keywords: [new jersey](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/new-jersey.md), [supreme court](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/supreme-court.md), [bloggers](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/bloggers.md), [journalism](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/journalism.md), [shield law](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/shield-law.md) ### Mark Shields, Finley Peter Dunne Name Drop - **Episode:** [276: Cleopatra Returns](https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/276-cleopatra-returns.md) - **Published:** 2011-02-06 - **Time:** 1:41:16–1:44:21 - **Transcript:** https://search.noagendashow.net/episode/276-cleopatra-returns/chapter/mark-shields-finley-peter-dunne-name-drop.md John C. Dvorak expresses frustration with PBS commentator Mark Shields for a "bogus" name-drop of writer Finley Peter Dunne. Dvorak's research into Dunne's 1896 works found no evidence of the quote Shields used regarding the Supreme Court. The segment highlights the difficulty of reading Dunne's dialect-heavy prose and the tendency of journalists to fabricate historical references. Keywords: [mark shields](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/mark-shields.md), [pbs](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/pbs.md), finley peter dunne, [law school](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/law-school.md), [gaelic](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/gaelic.md), [research](https://search.noagendashow.net/topic/research.md) --- This is the markdown version of a page on The No Agenda Show for AI agents. Every public page on this site has one: add `.md` to its URL, or request it with `Accept: text/markdown`. - [Site index for agents (llms.txt)](https://search.noagendashow.net/llms.txt) - [Home](https://search.noagendashow.net/index.md) - [Search transcripts](https://search.noagendashow.net/search.md) - [All episodes](https://search.noagendashow.net/episodes.md) - [Topics](https://search.noagendashow.net/topics.md) - [People](https://search.noagendashow.net/people.md)